Mitchell, NE

Our Outpost in the Western Valley

The Mitchell Valley is one of the key Ag areas in the Panhandle, and we are proud to have an office just for them. From Farm Insurance in Mitchell, Car Insurance in Morrill, or Center Pivot Insurance in Torrington, WY, Plummer Insurance’s Mitchell office can cover it all!

This satellite of our Gering office is open on Mondays and Wednesdays to serve people and businesses in Mitchell, NE, and the whole surrounding area. Stop in or give us a call.


Open Wednesdays

Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays:
CLOSED (call our Gering office)

Get In Touch

1273 Center Avenue
Mitchell, NE 69357
Google Map



Plummer Insurance
Based on 9 reviews
powered by Google
Somer PieperSomer Pieper
02:36 04 Feb 22
Kaden is always willing to answer questions and guide us on insurance related issues. He is kind, honest and trustworthy. The Mitchell office is very convenient!
Keelyn HubbardKeelyn Hubbard
00:08 04 Feb 22
Shelby WrightShelby Wright
22:37 03 Feb 22
Lex CarlsonLex Carlson
20:19 03 Feb 22
Top notch insurance experience, customer service 👌
Lanna HubbardLanna Hubbard
17:47 13 Sep 21

Insurance Services in Mitchell, NE

Center Pivots

Center Pivot Insurance in Torrington, WY, and Mitchell, NE is essential. See why Plummer Insurance is the highest rated at claim time.

Trucking Insurance

Semis move America, and Truck Insurance in Mitchell, NE and Torrington, WY is no joke. Start a quote with Plummer’s Trucking Insurance experts.

Employee Benefits

Our benefits experts can help you give them peace of mind – wether a small business in Morrill or Mitchell, NE, or a large employer in Torrington, WY. We keep your employees covered.

Crop insurance

For crop Insurance in Goshen County and Western Nebraska look no further than Plummer Insurance Agency in Mitchell, NE. We started in the heartland and we know Ag inside and out.

Auto Insurance

Car Insurance in Mitchell, NE and Goshen County has never been easier – comparison shop to see who has the cheapest rate with our online tool.

Livestock Risk Protection (LRP)

Ranchers in Mitchell and Feedlots in Torrington will find LRP to be their lowest risk price hedge.

Business Insurance

High Plains businesses – from large companies to small businesses – have a new option for commercial and business insurance in Torrington, WY and Mitchell, NE.

Contractor Insurance

Worker’s Compensation, Jobsite Equipment Insurance and more for contractors, plumbers, electricians and subcontractors in Mitchell, NE and Torrington, WY.

Request More Information

Start your new policy or shoot us over any questions you might have by filling out the form on this page, and an agent will be in touch with you soon.

Looking for a Home or Auto Quote? Shop rates from multiple companies with our rate comparison tool.

Send Us a Message

Send Us a Message