Plummer Insurance, Inc. Acquires Classic One Insurance

Scottsbluff, Nebraska – Plummer Insurance, Inc. today announced the acquisition of Classic One Insurance from Riverstone Bank, effective March 15, 2024.

Mike Downey, CEO of Riverstone Bank said “One of the most important factors when we considered selling Classic One Insurance, was how well our customers would be taken care of.  We are very pleased that we were able to sell to a local agency like Plummer Insurance, with an excellent reputation for customer service and a variety of insurance products.  Another important consideration was the retention of our excellent employees. By maintaining their employment, they will be available to help make the transition for our loyal customers as seamless as possible.  We felt like the decision was a win, win, win for everyone involved.”

Classic One Insurance will remain at its current Scottsbluff location for the immediate future, but will eventually move to Plummer Insurance’s new Gering location at 1436 10th Street.

“With insurance premiums and deductibles on the rise, we are looking forward to the opportunity to offer additional products and company choices to Classic One customers,” said Plummer Insurance President, Andrew Plummer. “We are especially excited for the opportunity to improve efficiencies and expand expertise in our agency by adding the current Classic One staff members and we look forward to meeting policyholders as we make this transition.”

Plummer Insurance was established in 1984 by Steve and Helen Plummer. The agency currently has nine locations in Western Nebraska and Eastern Colorado and offers multiple insurance products, including home, auto, farm, life, health, crop, bonds, business/commercial, truck, and specialty insurance, by several highly-rated insurance companies.