Sidney, NE

Personal and Business Insurance Coverage

Your home for insurance on I-80.

Sidney has been a stopping point for the explorers among us as long as Nebraska has been explored. From the Pony Express to the Sidney-Deadwood trail, to the longest interstate highway in the nation, Sidney is one of the places where the West was Won. Plummer Insurance is proud to be your insurance store in Sidney, NE.

Our office in Sidney offers all of our insurance services, including Employee Benefits; Industrial and Contractor Insurance; Small Business Insurance; and of course affordable car insurance. Not to mention, if you’re looking for Commercial Trucking or Farm and Crop insurance in Cheyenne County, Plummer is the place to call.


Monday thru Thursday
8AM – 5PM
Friday: 8AM – 3PM

Get In Touch

418 Glover Road
Sidney, NE 69162
Google Map



Plummer Insurance
Based on 31 reviews
powered by Google
Edmund Moran IVEdmund Moran IV
16:24 25 Apr 23
Sarah is always a delight to work with. In addition to securing me new policies with the same (or greater) coverage at lower rates Sarah is always eager to hop on the phone and answer any questions I may have. I never have to worry about the unknown. Thank you for giving me peace of mind!!
Kylie CrandallKylie Crandall
23:38 21 Apr 23
Excellent experience! The broker offered practical insight on what coverage we needed and how to maximize that coverage. All the coverage was reasonably priced. We will be back for any future insurance needs.
Angie SwopeAngie Swope
17:03 21 Apr 23
We have used Jaime Smirich for all our insurance needs and never had any issues. She's always available to answer any questions or concerns we have! I'd definitely recommend Plummer Insurance for your insurance needs!
Kelly RobbKelly Robb
23:41 18 Apr 23
Cindy goes the extra mile every time I need help with my insurance! Everyone in the office is so pleasant!
Sara Von SeggernSara Von Seggern
22:53 18 Apr 23
Great customer service! Always quick responses, very helpful, and some of the kindest people working to get the best insurance quotes for their customers.
Jennifer VJennifer V
20:57 13 Mar 23
Sarah was great to work with. She explained everything thoroughly and made sure that our coverage was exactly what we needed.
Carson FaesslerCarson Faessler
02:36 18 Nov 22
Jaime was great and made the process so easy getting all my insurance stuff switched over! She went above and beyond to make sure I got the best rate! Great customer service! Thank you!!!
Regina PersingerRegina Persinger
22:55 17 Nov 22
We opened a new business and Jaime took the time to find out what type of policy we needed and how much coverage, then gave me several options to choose from and which one she recommended would best suit our business. She is very professional and knows her products! We couldn't be more pleased with Jaime as our insurance agent!
Kelly ReimersKelly Reimers
19:50 01 Apr 22
We have the pleasure of having Jaime S as our Insurance Agent and she goes above and beyond for us every time, she is timely with her responses to us, and she always has our best interest in mind so she shops around rates when possible. We are so fortunate to have her in our corner!
Jenny SJenny S
20:57 09 Feb 22
I had the pleasure to do business with Jamie. She is the model of true customer service and professionalism. She's informative and truly cares about her clients' business needs. I highly recommend her as your agent.
Diana GoodwinDiana Goodwin
18:25 09 Feb 22
Rob Robinson has been our insurance agent for many years.  He’s always been knowledgeable, professional, and honest.  We always knew exactly what our policy covered, and paid a fair premium.  Would recommend Rob or any agent at the Plummer Agency.

Insurance Services in Sidney, NE

Employee Benefits

Our benefits experts can help you give your employees peace of mind, no matter what size your business is.

Crop insurance

For crop Insurance in Western Nebraska look no further than Plummer Insurance Agency in Sidney. We started in the heartland and we know Ag inside and out.

Business Insurance

Sidney and Chappell Businesses – from large companies to small businesses – have a new option for commercial insurance with Plummer.

Center Pivots

Center Pivots are essential on Nebraska’s Western Edge – high elevation and wind exposure require coverage. See why Plummer Insurance is the highest rated at claim time.

Auto Insurance

Car Insurance in Sidney has never been easier – comparison shop to see who has the cheapest rate with our online tool.

Trucking Insurance

Located right on America’s busiest trucking artery, Truck Insurance in Sidney, NE is serious business. Start a quote with Plummer’s Trucking Insurance experts.

Livestock Risk Protection (LRP)

Ranchers in Sidney will find LRP to be their lowest risk price hedge.

Contractor Insurance

Worker’s Compensation, Jobsite Equipment Insurance and more for contractors, plumbers, electricians and subcontractors in Sidney.

Request More Information

Start your new policy or shoot us over any questions you might have by filling out the form on this page, and an agent will be in touch with you soon.

Looking for a Home or Auto Quote? Shop rates from multiple companies with our rate comparison tool.

Send Us a Message

Send Us a Message