Gering, NE

Covering the Twin Cities and the North Platte Valley

We’ve moved! New location just across 10th Street.

Your home for insurance in Scottsbluff and Gering.

Plummer Insurance serves the entire Nebraska Panhandle from our location on 10th Street in Gering, Nebraska’s business district, as well as providing insurance in Torrington, Wyoming and the rest of Goshen and Laramie Counties.

Our Gering office has specialists in Commercial and Business Insurance, Employee Benefits, Farmowner and Center Pivot Policies, and Personal Home, Renter’s and Car Insurance in Scottsbluff and Gering.

Plummer Insurance also has experts in Truck Insurance and Crop Insurance, including Livestock Revenue Protection. Call our Gering office today, or use the “Request a Quote” button to get more information.


Monday thru Thursday 8AM – 5PM
Friday 8AM – 3PM

Get In Touch

1436 10th Street
Gering, NE 69341
Google Map



Plummer Insurance
Based on 27 reviews
powered by Google
Reba DodgeReba Dodge
01:20 04 Apr 23
I appreciate the professionalism and personal attention we have received since doing buisness with Plummer Insurance. It's not everyday that we talk or engage in business, but when you find yourself in a pickle or something has happened to your property - they got your back.
Moett MaagMoett Maag
18:41 24 Mar 23
Melissa Aguallo is amazing. She is prompt, respectful, and gets the best rates possible. My husband and I were able to stop in to the local office in Gering , was greeted by the receptionist and was able to speak with Melissa directly with no wait time. The job field I am in doesn’t allow for me to have my phone, and I am able to communicate with Melissa via email efficiently. I have never had any complaints regarding Melissa! Thank you Melissa for all you do for your customers, your work doesn’t go unnoticed!
Ramon MedinaRamon Medina
14:07 13 Mar 23
Luke did a great job of insuring my construction company and continues to work with us by responding rapidly to the changing needs of my growing business. Staff at the office is professional, capable, available to help, and willing to take the extra step to get what we need. I recommend this agency for insuring and bonding your business.
Ben HardyBen Hardy
15:59 09 Mar 23
I switched to Plummer last fall and my agent, Luke, saved me a ton of money!
Diana MartinDiana Martin
23:34 10 Nov 22
Kristie has been very helpful when I needed to add a car and a house to my existing policies... I have been with plummer insurance for many years, they have always come through whenever I need something!
Doug CouseDoug Couse
19:13 26 Oct 22
Awesome customer service! Luke, Mike, Andrew…everyone there is extremely helpful.Just need a quote, no problem!Need insurance on a trailer you just bought? No problem.They’ve helped me multiple times.I love the personal, know your customer service they provide me.Thanks!
Emerald MMEmerald MM
18:57 02 Mar 22
We have been with Plummer Insurance for a 7 years now...Luke Johnson and the team have always been the MOST helpful for any situation we have been in. We keep coming back, because we really get the absolute best deal for our insurance coverage...can't be beat! So happy we found Plummer Insurance. Thank you Luke !!!!
Todd BoggsTodd Boggs
14:02 30 Oct 21
Mike and Luke made the process simple. They were very helpful with questions and were able to get me great coverage to fit my needs in all areas of business and personal insurance. Oh yeah, they saved me tons of 'dough' too!!

Insurance Services in Gering, NE

Business Insurance

Plummer Insurance is the industry leader in Business Insurance in Scottsbluff and Gering – providing general Liability and more to firms of all sizes.

Employee Benefits

Our benefits experts can help you give your employees peace of mind – whether a small business in Gering or a large employer in Scottsbluff. We keep your employees covered.

Contractor Insurance

Worker’s Compensation, General Liability, Jobsite Equipment Coverage and more; Plummer Insurance offers the most options for subcontractor and contractor insurance in Scottsbluff and Gering.

Auto Insurance

Car Insurance in Gering and Scottsbluff County has never been easier – comparison shop to see who has the cheapest rate with our online tool.

Center Pivots

Pivot Sprinklers keep the Valley going, even through the dry times. See why when it comes to Sprinkler Insurance in Scottsbluff and Gering, Plummer Insurance is the highest rated at claim time.

Trucking Insurance

Start a quote with Plummer’s Trucking Insurance experts and see why they are the valley’s favorite for trucking lines of all sizes.

Livestock Risk Protection (LRP)

Ranchers and feedlots in Sioux, Banner, and Scottsbluff Counties will find LRP to be their secret weapon – and lowest risk price hedge against volatile markets

Crop insurance

Plummer Insurance started in the heartland and we know Ag inside and out. Our Crop insurance team can give you protection on every acre.

Request More Information

Start your new policy or shoot us over any questions you might have by filling out the form on this page, and an agent will be in touch with you soon.

Looking for a Home or Auto Quote? Shop rates from multiple companies with our rate comparison tool.

Send Us a Message

Send Us a Message